Unfair dismissal and redundancy evidence, United Kingdom
Unfair Redundancy or Dismissal?
Save the Evidence Before You Are Locked Out
To prove unfair dismissal or unfair redundancy in the UK in 2026, save copies of your contract, appraisals, HR emails, chats and dismissal letter before you lose access. ProofSnap seals each page as a signed, hashed evidence package of 11 to 15 files. Dismissed on or after 1 October 2026? Notify Acas within 6 months less 1 day.
By Radim Motycka, founder of ProofSnap, who builds forensic web capture and evidence-packaging tools for disputes · Last updated
Your employer controls the email servers, the Teams workspace, the HR system and every appraisal you have ever been given. ProofSnap captures what those systems hold in a form a solicitor can verify independently: timestamped, hashed and packaged for an employment tribunal, one page at a time.
Also available for Microsoft Edge
SnapPack: $4.99, one-off (approx. £3.80) · 7-day free trial, payment card required, cancel at any time
Employment tribunal evidence · Acas early conciliation · Employment Rights Act 1996 and Equality Act 2010 · Works with your solicitor’s case file
How to prove unfair dismissal in the UK: quick answers
- Can I claim unfair dismissal?
- Yes, if you have two or more years of continuous service and your employer either had no fair reason or did not follow a fair procedure. The Employment Rights Act 2025 will cut the qualifying period to six months, not to day one, and that change is legislated but not yet in force: commencement is set for 1 January 2027. Discrimination claims have no service requirement at all.
- What evidence do I need?
- Employment contract, dismissal letter, performance reviews, HR emails, Slack/Teams messages, grievance correspondence, redundancy selection criteria, payslips.
- How long do I have to lodge a claim?
- If your effective date of termination fell on or after 1 October 2026, you must notify Acas within 6 months less 1 day; for an earlier dismissal the limit stays at 3 months less 1 day. Notifying Acas pauses the clock while early conciliation runs, for up to 12 weeks, and you then have at least one month from the certificate to lodge the ET1.
- Will a screenshot hold up?
- Tribunals accept WhatsApp and Teams messages, and the volume is rising fast: employment tribunal cases involving WhatsApp messages went from 48 in 2018 to 562 in 2024, according to Salford Business School researchers writing in The Conversation in June 2025. A bare screenshot is still easy to attack as edited or out of context, which is why an authenticated capture that your solicitor can verify independently carries more weight.
- What about collective redundancy?
- If 20 or more employees at one establishment are proposed for redundancy within 90 days, your employer must start consulting representatives at least 30 days before the first dismissal, or 45 days where 100 or more are proposed. For dismissals on or after 6 April 2026 the maximum protective award doubles from 90 to 180 days’ pay per employee.
- Not dismissed yet, but can you see it coming?
- Start capturing now: appraisals, HR emails, Teams messages with your manager. Once your access is revoked it is too late. The 7-day ProofSnap trial requires a payment card and can be cancelled at any time; the one-off SnapPack is the alternative if you would rather not start a subscription.
3 steps to tribunal-ready unfair dismissal evidence
ProofSnap captures evidence of your employment in a form an employment tribunal can admit and your solicitor can check independently.
Install ProofSnap
Add the Chrome or Edge extension. Start the 7-day trial, which requires a payment card, or buy a one-off SnapPack.
Capture Before You Lose Access
Open your work email, Slack, Teams or HR portal and click ProofSnap. It captures the rendered page, the page source, the extracted text and the server details, then seals the lot with SHA-256 hashes and an RSA-signed manifest.
Lodge Your Claim
Download the evidence package, which holds 11 to 15 files depending on your plan. Notify Acas for early conciliation, then lodge the ET1 or hand the package to your solicitor.
Made redundant by email, locked out of everything: how the evidence disappears
These are the patterns that come up again and again in UK tribunal cases. Without your own copies, your claim rests on what your employer chooses to disclose.
Dismissed by text, email or video call
P&O Ferries dismissed about 800 seafarers by pre-recorded video in March 2022. In Miluska v Roman Property Group, a pregnant consultant was dismissed by text message with a jazz-hands emoji, and the tribunal awarded £93,616.74. Employers increasingly dismiss by email or Teams call, locking you out of the systems before the meeting ends.
Evidence needed: the dismissal message itself, the employment contract, and the consultation records, or proof that there were none
Systems locked immediately
VPN, Teams, email, SharePoint and badge access are usually revoked at the same moment. Your employer then controls every piece of evidence: appraisals, grievance records and internal communications.
Evidence needed: capture everything BEFORE your access is cut
Performance reviews rewritten
Your last three appraisals said “Exceeds Expectations”. Now HR claims your performance was “below standard” and that’s why you were selected for redundancy. The positive reviews have vanished from the HR portal.
Evidence needed: timestamped capture of performance reviews in BambooHR/Workday
Teams and WhatsApp messages deleted
Your manager’s discriminatory comments in Teams. The WhatsApp group where they joked about your age/pregnancy/disability. The HR chat where they admitted the real reason. All deleted the day you were dismissed. In Brosnan v Coalo, leaving a disabled employee out of the work WhatsApp group was part of a discrimination finding worth about £134,400.
Evidence needed: Teams and WhatsApp messages with your manager and with HR, captured before deletion
Grievance “lost” by HR
You raised a grievance about discrimination. HR acknowledged it. Months later, you’re made “redundant”. HR claims no record of your grievance exists, and your subject access request comes back incomplete.
Evidence needed: grievance email, HR acknowledgement, any follow-up correspondence
A “redundancy” that is not genuine
You returned from maternity leave, or raised a health and safety concern, or blew the whistle. Three weeks later, your role was “made redundant”. They’re already advertising your job on LinkedIn. In Osborn v Mothercare, WhatsApp messages showed the redundancy was a sham, and £67,801 was awarded.
Evidence needed: your complaint, the timing of the redundancy, the LinkedIn job advert for your role
Your employer controls all the evidence, unless you capture it first
Email servers, Teams workspaces, HR systems, appraisal databases, security pass logs and payroll records all live on your employer’s infrastructure. You can submit a subject access request under the UK GDPR, but your employer has one month to respond and the response can come back incomplete. Without independent, timestamped copies of your own, your tribunal claim depends entirely on what your employer chooses to disclose.
42,000 single tribunal claims in 2024/25 (Ministry of Justice, Tribunal Statistics Quarterly). Average unfair dismissal award £13,749, median £6,746 (Ministry of Justice, 2023/24 award statistics). Discrimination and whistleblowing awards are uncapped.
Documented evidence changes the outcome long before the claim reaches a hearing.
Save Your Evidence, 7 Days FreeUnfair dismissal and redundancy cases won in the UK: what the evidence showed
Real outcomes. In each one, the evidence made the difference.
Brosnan v Coalo (2023). Mark Brosnan, a plumber whose back injury was assessed as a disability, was left out of the work WhatsApp group while he was absent. The tribunal found the exclusion was because of his absence, and therefore because of his disability. He resigned after the recommended adjustments were not made, and the total award came to about £134,400, covering loss of earnings, injury to feelings, personal injury and unfair dismissal.
Source: GOV.UK Tribunal Decision, Personnel Today
Miluska v Roman Property Group (2025). Paula Miluska, a pregnant consultant, was dismissed by text message. Her employer sent a “deliberately vague” message ending with a jazz-hands emoji. The text message itself was the evidence. The tribunal found the intent obvious: she was dismissed over pregnancy-related illness. The award was £93,616.74 for pregnancy discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Source: People Management, LBC
Osborn v Mothercare (2024). Nichola Osborn returned from maternity leave and within a month was told her role was “at risk of redundancy”. WhatsApp messages showed her managers had planned to replace her while she was still on leave. The tribunal called it a sham rather than a genuine redundancy and awarded £67,801, including £20,000 for injury to feelings.
Source: People Management, GB News
Borg-Neal v Lloyds Banking Group (2023). Carl Borg-Neal, a manager with dyslexia, was dismissed for gross misconduct after repeating an offensive word during a race education session. The evidence showed his dyslexia made him blurt words out. Lloyds failed to account for his disability. The total award exceeded £470,000, including £309,867 for future loss of earnings and £23,000 for the depression the dismissal caused.
Source: Aaron & Partners, GOV.UK Tribunal Judgment
In each case the written record carried the claim. Make sure yours still exists when you need it.
Capture Your Evidence, 7 Days FreeWhat evidence do you need to prove unfair dismissal?
To prove unfair dismissal at an employment tribunal you need evidence that your employer either had no fair reason for the dismissal or did not follow a fair procedure under the Employment Rights Act 1996. The specific evidence depends on your situation, as the lists below show.
Note what the tribunal is actually deciding. Admissibility is rarely the fight, because rule 41(3) of the Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 provides: “The Tribunal is not bound by any rule of law relating to the admissibility of evidence in proceedings before the courts.” Your screenshot can be put before the tribunal. The fight is over weight, and that is where an authenticated capture beats a picture of a screen.
Core evidence (all claims):
- • Employment contract / offer letter
- • Dismissal letter or redundancy notice
- • Performance reviews / appraisals
- • Payslips and benefits records
- • Any written communications about the dismissal
Situation-specific:
- • Sham redundancy: LinkedIn job adverts, selection scoring, consultation notes
- • Discrimination: WhatsApp/Teams messages, emails showing bias
- • Victimisation: grievance records, how soon the dismissal followed the complaint
- • Constructive dismissal: evidence of the breach before you resign
Critical: all of this evidence lives on your employer’s systems. The moment they dismiss you, they revoke access, and a subject access request takes a month. ProofSnap captures verifiable copies before you lose access.
Your screenshot versus their legal team
You lodge a tribunal claim with a screenshot. Your employer answers with HR records, server logs and timestamped system data, plus a solicitor who argues your screenshot was fabricated. The tribunal will admit both. The question is which one it believes, and that is a question of weight.
Your Screenshot
- No proof of when it was taken
- Anyone can fake it in 30 seconds
- No way to verify it came from a real web page
- No audit trail, just a picture
- Just one file
- Their solicitor will tear it apart
ProofSnap Evidence Package
- Independent timestamp showing the files existed no later than the moment of capture (OpenTimestamps from Professional, eIDAS on Enterprise)
- SHA-256 integrity check, so any later edit to the file is detected
- Full server details: URL, IP address, DNS records and HTTP headers
- Forensic log and chain of custody recording who captured what, when and how
- 11 to 15 files: screenshot, page source, PDF report, metadata, plus an optional video
- Verifiable by the other side, by your solicitor and by the tribunal, using the included scripts or the Trust Verifier
Compensatory award capped at £123,543 for dismissals on or after 6 April 2026 (Employment Rights (Increase of Limits) Order 2026), cap removed from 1 January 2027 under the Employment Rights Act 2025 · discrimination and whistleblowing awards uncapped
Employment tribunals cover Great Britain, that is England, Wales and Scotland. Northern Ireland has its own Industrial Tribunals and Fair Employment Tribunal under separate legislation, so the deadlines and figures on this page should be checked against Northern Irish rules if you work there.
Already dismissed, or can you see it coming? Capture these in the next 10 minutes
If you still have access to work systems, every minute matters, because once you are locked out the evidence is gone. If you have already been locked out, capture what is still reachable: forwarded emails, LinkedIn messages and any personal copies.
Your emergency capture checklist:
Why this matters even if you already have screenshots: your employer’s solicitors can argue that a screenshot was edited, cropped or taken out of context. ProofSnap creates evidence that is far harder to dispute, because each capture is cryptographically sealed with a timestamp your solicitor can verify independently. That is the difference between a claim that turns on your word and one that turns on the record.
Do the maths:
$4.99 (approx. £3.80) to protect a claim in a category where the average award was £13,749 in 2023/24 (Ministry of Justice employment tribunal statistics). Discrimination and whistleblowing awards are uncapped. The 7-day trial is enough to gather a full set of evidence, and it requires a payment card.
Or start with a one-off SnapPack: $4.99 (approx. £3.80) for 10 captures.
Already locked out of Teams, email and the VPN?
You can still capture critical evidence. Use ProofSnap on your personal computer to document:
Every piece of evidence you capture now strengthens your tribunal claim. For a dismissal taking effect on or after 1 October 2026 you have 6 months less 1 day from the effective date of termination to notify Acas; for an earlier one, 3 months less 1 day. Do not let the clock run out before you have the evidence.
Is your redundancy genuine? Examples of unfair redundancy and four checks to run today
In Osborn v Mothercare, WhatsApp messages proved the “redundancy” was planned before the employee returned from maternity leave. The tribunal called it a “sham”. Here’s how to check yours:
1. Check their careers page and LinkedIn
Search for your job title on your employer’s website and LinkedIn. If they’re hiring for your role (or a suspiciously similar one), the redundancy may not be genuine. Capture it with ProofSnap before they take it down.
2. Check the selection criteria
Were you scored fairly? Were others in the “pool” genuinely considered? If you were the only one “at risk” and your role still exists, that is not a redundancy; it is an unfair dismissal.
3. Check the timing
Did the “redundancy” come shortly after you returned from maternity or parental leave, raised a grievance, reported a health and safety concern or made a protected disclosure? Timing is evidence.
4. Check your replacement
Has a new recruit or a contractor been brought in to do your job? If your employer’s need for employees to do work of your kind has not “ceased or diminished”, the redundancy is not genuine under section 139 of the Employment Rights Act 1996.
Reading this on your phone?
ProofSnap is a browser extension, so you will need a laptop or desktop computer. Email this link to yourself and install ProofSnap tomorrow morning before work.
Email me the installation linkHow to bring an unfair dismissal claim, step by step
You have your ProofSnap evidence package. Now lodge your claim. Choose the path that matches your situation.
Step 1: Acas early conciliation (mandatory, free)
- 1. Section 111 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 gives you six months beginning with your effective date of termination to bring the claim, in practice 6 months less 1 day, if that date fell on or after 1 October 2026, and 3 months less 1 day for an earlier one. You must notify Acas before that limit runs out; this step is mandatory before any tribunal claim.
- 2. Notifying Acas pauses your time limit. A conciliator then tries to resolve the dispute, free of charge, and early conciliation can run for up to 12 weeks.
- 3. If no agreement is reached, Acas issues an early conciliation certificate. From the date you receive it you have at least one month left to lodge your ET1.
Step 2: the employment tribunal claim (free to lodge)
- 1. After Acas conciliation, submit your ET1 to the employment tribunal. Lodging a claim is free: tribunal fees were quashed in 2017 in R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51.
- 2. Keep your ProofSnap evidence package ready for disclosure and the hearing bundle. The 11 to 15 files it contains, hashed and listed in a signed manifest, carry more weight than bare screenshots.
- 3. Your employer has 28 days to respond with its ET3. The tribunal may then list the claim for a preliminary hearing.
- 4. The tribunal caseload is under strain: single-claim receipts rose 23% year on year to 42,000 in 2024/25 (Ministry of Justice, Tribunal Statistics Quarterly), so act early rather than wait for the deadline.
Subject access request: get your employer’s copy of the data
- 1. Under the UK GDPR, submit a subject access request to your employer, free of charge. Your employer must provide the personal data it holds about you within one month.
- 2. That includes emails, HR records, appraisals, disciplinary files, CCTV and internal messages that mention you.
- 3. If your employer does not comply, complain to the Information Commissioner’s Office.
- 4. A subject access request still takes a month. Data can go missing in that time. Your own copies mean you have evidence even if the disclosure comes back incomplete, and they show you exactly what is missing.
Employment solicitor (unfair dismissal, settlement negotiation)
- 1. Many employment solicitors offer a free first consultation, and some act on a conditional fee (no win, no fee) basis in strong cases.
- 2. Arrive with your ProofSnap evidence package. Solicitors triage cases by evidence quality, and a package of 11 to 15 files with hashes, a signed manifest and a chain of custody reads very differently from a folder of screenshots.
- 3. Alternatively, get free advice from Citizens Advice, your trade union or Acas.
All of these paths run on documented evidence. ProofSnap creates the forensic package you hand to Acas, the tribunal or your solicitor.
Start NowAcas early conciliation is free and mandatory, and it pauses your deadline
Acas dealt with more than 117,000 individual disputes in 2024/25, up 13,000 on the previous year, and helped resolve 9 out of 10 early conciliation cases without an employment tribunal (Acas, 2025). It is free, it is mandatory before any tribunal claim, and notifying Acas pauses your time limit.
Share your ProofSnap evidence package during conciliation. Documented, timestamped evidence strengthens your position when you negotiate.
Works with every workplace platform
If it opens in Chrome, ProofSnap can capture it.
ProofSnap is not affiliated with any employer or workplace platform. Platform names are listed for information only.
The settlement agreement trap: do not sign away your rights without evidence
Your employer offers a settlement agreement in exchange for waiving all claims. Before you sign, understand exactly what you are giving up, and what evidence you need in order to negotiate a better deal.
What they want you to sign:
- Waiver of all employment claims (unfair dismissal, discrimination)
- Non-disparagement clause (you can’t talk about what happened)
- Confidentiality (you can’t share the settlement terms)
- Agreed reference, often bland, which fixes what your employer will say about you
Your legal protections:
- Independent legal advice required: the agreement does not bind you without it
- Employers commonly pay a few hundred pounds towards your legal fees, though no statute fixes the amount
- The first £30,000 of a genuine termination payment is normally free of income tax
- Evidence of wrongdoing gives you leverage for a higher settlement
Capture the settlement agreement with ProofSnap before you sign. This creates a timestamped record of exactly what terms were offered, when, and by whom. If the terms change or your employer later disputes what was offered, you have proof.
What your evidence is worth in settlement negotiations:
The Vento bands were uprated with effect from 6 April 2026 by the Presidents of the Employment Tribunals: £1,300 to £12,600 (lower), £12,600 to £37,700 (middle), £37,700 to £62,900 (upper), with the most exceptional cases capable of exceeding £62,900. An injury to feelings award sits on top of compensation for lost earnings; see what tribunals actually awarded in 47 cases with message evidence. Documented evidence of discrimination is what lets you negotiate from a position of strength.
Employment tribunal time limit in 2026: work out your Acas deadline
- System access revoked within minutes, taking emails, Teams history and appraisals with it
- Acas first: 6 months less 1 day for dismissals on or after 1 October 2026, 3 months less 1 day before that. Strictly enforced.
Start capturing evidence now
7-day free trial included with all plans. Cancel at any time.
7-day free trial, payment card required, cancel at any time
Essential
approx. £6.80
100 captures/month
- Evidence package of 11 files (12 on Professional, 15 on Enterprise)
- Video of the capture process
- Provenance Certificate
- File Certification, 5 a month
- Blockchain timestamp
- eIDAS qualified timestamp
Regular use, archiving
Professional
approx. £12.90
200 captures/month
- Everything in Essential
- Blockchain (OpenTimestamps)
- File Certification, 15 a month
- eIDAS qualified timestamp
Blockchain timestamping, audit-grade
Enterprise
approx. £22.00
Unlimited captures
- Everything in Professional
- eIDAS qualified timestamp via Disig a.s., a Qualified Trust Service Provider on the EU Trusted List
- File Certification, 50 a month
- Email support, response within 1 working day
Litigation and compliance teams
Just been made redundant? Start here.
SnapPack: $4.99, one-off (approx. £3.80)
10 captures, a one-off purchase, no subscription and no auto-renewal. The captures never expire.
Ten captures cover the whole checklist: appraisals, contract, HR emails, Teams messages, payslips, the dismissal letter, the settlement agreement and the LinkedIn advert for your role.
Get a SnapPack, $4.99 (approx. £3.80)Annual plans cost $80, $160 and $280 (approx. £61, £122 and £213) instead of $107.88, $203.88 and $347.88, a saving of roughly a fifth to a quarter. All prices are charged in US dollars by Stripe; the sterling figures are approximate. See all pricing options
Would you rather not do it yourself? Our managed evidence capture service starts at $44.99 per URL (approx. £34) and falls to $29.80 per URL (approx. £23) on the larger bundles.
Not sure yet? Download a sample evidence package
Unfair dismissal evidence: frequently asked questions
A qualified timestamp also carries a statutory presumption as to the accuracy of its date and time and the integrity of the data it is bound to. UK law continues to recognise timestamps that are qualified under EU law, as our guide to eIDAS qualified timestamps in UK law explains. In a tribunal, though, what decides your claim is weight: a bare screenshot gets in and counts for little, while a hashed and signed package with a full chain of custody, verification scripts and a timestamp anyone can check counts for a great deal. ProofSnap issues the qualified timestamp through Disig a.s., a Qualified Trust Service Provider on the EU Trusted List.
Still have questions? Start with the free trial.
7 days, payment card required, cancel at any time. See the evidence package for yourself.
UK employment rights resources
Acas dealt with more than 117,000 individual disputes in 2024/25 and helped resolve 9 out of 10 early conciliation cases without a tribunal (Acas, 2025). The system works, and it runs on documented evidence.
Acas
Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service. Free advice, mandatory early conciliation before tribunal claims.
Citizens Advice
Free employment law guidance. Covers unfair dismissal, redundancy, discrimination and tribunal claims.
GOV.UK: making an employment tribunal claim
Official guide to making a claim. Free to lodge. ET1 form and process explained.
ICO: your data rights
Information Commissioner’s Office. Submit subject access requests and report data protection breaches.
EHRC
Equality and Human Rights Commission. Enforces the Equality Act 2010 and intervenes in discrimination cases.
GOV.UK: redundancy rights and pay
Statutory redundancy pay calculator, notice periods, consultation requirements.
Evidence guides by jurisdiction
In Australia? The deadline is far shorter: an unfair dismissal application must reach the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect. See unfair dismissal evidence in Australia.