ProofSnap study AI chat evidence 2,401 share links, 2023 to 2026

One in five ChatGPT share links posted on Hacker News no longer opens the conversation

In November 2026, ProofSnap opened all 2,401 ChatGPT share links that the Hacker News search API returns for posts since May 2023 to see whether the conversation was still there. Of these, 478 (19.9%) no longer opened it, and among links more than two years old, the figure was 24.4%. A share link is not a record.

19.9%of 2,401 shared conversations no longer open
24.4%of links posted more than two years ago are gone
17.8%of links posted 3 to 12 months ago are already gone
Portrait of Radim Motycka
By Radim Motycka, founder and lead engineer of ProofSnap
ยท 6 min read

A ProofSnap study of 2,401 ChatGPT share links posted on Hacker News between May 2023 and November 2026 found that 478 (19.9%) no longer opened the shared conversation when checked on November 19, 2026. Among links posted more than two years earlier, 24.4% were gone.

Finding 1

Links over two years old are the most likely to be gone

The Share button in ChatGPT turns a conversation into a public URL under chatgpt.com/share/, readable by anyone who has it. These URLs travel as proof of what a model said: a striking answer, a wrong one, a bug report, a research note.

Hacker News makes their fate measurable. Every comment and story there is dated, and nobody posts a share link by accident. The search API returned 2,401 distinct shared conversations, the earliest from May 27, 2023, and each one was opened on November 19, 2026.

In ProofSnap's November 2026 check, even among links less than three months old, 6.6% no longer opened. Between three and twelve months, the rate was 17.8%, and past two years almost a quarter. The rate for links one to two years old (14.3%) is slightly lower than for links three to twelve months old, so the trend is not a straight line. What every age group shows is that a share link cannot be relied on to last.

Share link no longer opens the conversation By time since first posted on Hacker News, 2,401 links
  • Under 3 months (91 links)6.6%
  • 3 to 12 months (264 links)17.8%
  • 1 to 2 years (733 links)14.3%
  • Over 2 years (1,313 links)24.4%
  • All links19.9%

Age measured from the first posting on Hacker News to the check on November 19, 2026. Source: ProofSnap analysis of Hacker News items and chatgpt.com share pages, November 2026.

Finding 2

The first wave of shared chats has lost the most

Of the conversations first shared in 2023, 29.0% are gone. For links first posted in 2024 the figure is 17.3%, and for 2025 and 2026, 14.6% each.

The early links mostly used the older URL format, chat.openai.com/share/, which now redirects to chatgpt.com. Of the 1,005 conversations shared under the old URL, 27.2% are gone, compared with 14.7% of the 1,396 shared under the new one. Every link was checked at the current URL, so the redirect itself is not the cause. Age explains most of the gap, though perhaps not all of it: among links first posted in 2024, when both URLs were in use, 21.1% of those under the old URL are gone, compared with 15.0% under the new one.

For comparison, Pew Research Center found that 38% of web pages that existed in 2013 were no longer accessible a decade later (When Online Content Disappears, 2024). The two samples differ: Pew drew pages from the web at large, while every share link here can be deleted by one person at any time. Even so, the 2023 links lost 29% in under three and a half years.

29.0%

of 777 conversations first shared in 2023 no longer open

17.3%

of 602 conversations first shared in 2024

14.6%

of 721 conversations first shared in 2025

14.6%

of 301 conversations first shared in 2026, through November 17

Year of first posting on Hacker News. Source: ProofSnap analysis, November 2026.

Finding 3

The Wayback Machine held 76 of 478 lost chats, all under the old address

Each of the 478 lost conversations was looked up in the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine on November 19, 2026. It held a copy with the conversation for 76 of them (15.9%). Every one of those was shared under the old chat.openai.com address, and 66 of the copies were made in 2023. Of the 273 lost links under that address, which could all be checked, 76 (27.8%) had a copy.

For the 205 lost links under chatgpt.com, no copy could be retrieved. The Wayback Machine answered every lookup of a chatgpt.com/share/ address we tried with HTTP 403 (Forbidden), in its index and in playback, while lookups of the chatgpt.com home page and of the old address worked at the same time. So 15.9% is a lower bound: whether the archive holds any of those 205 could not be tested. In practice, not one conversation lost from 2025 or 2026 could be recovered from it.

Nine further captures under the old address held only a redirect to the new domain, not the conversation, and are not counted.

15.9%

of 478 lost conversations could be retrieved from the Wayback Machine

27.8%

of 273 lost links under chat.openai.com, where lookups worked

0 of 205

lost links under chatgpt.com could be retrieved

0 of 149

conversations lost from 2025 and 2026 could be retrieved, all under chatgpt.com, where lookups returned HTTP 403

Wayback Machine CDX index and earliest capture with status 200, checked November 19, 2026. Source: ProofSnap analysis.

Finding 4

Claude share links and Wikipedia citations decay too

Two comparison samples, checked the same day, show that the problem is not limited to ChatGPT or to Hacker News.

Claude. Of 296 Claude share links posted on Hacker News, 40 (13.5%) no longer opened the conversation. Each was opened in a full browser: a live link shows "This is a copy of a chat between Claude and" the person who shared it, while a removed one sends the visitor to the sign-in page, as a share address that cannot exist does.

Wikipedia. On 13 Wikipedia language editions, 270 ChatGPT share links are linked from pages today. Only three sit in articles; most of the rest appear where editors argue: deletion debates and noticeboards, talk pages and user pages. Of the 270, 25 (9.3%) no longer opened. About half of these links are younger than a year; among the 69 created one to two years earlier, 12 (17.4%) were gone.

Gemini was not measured: Google answered the automated checks with an "unusual traffic" page.

19.9%

of 2,401 ChatGPT links on Hacker News no longer open

13.5%

of 296 Claude links on Hacker News

9.3%

of 270 ChatGPT links on 13 Wikipedia editions, about half younger than a year

3 of 270

Wikipedia links sit in an article; the rest are in discussions

All checked November 19, 2026, with a second check of every link classified as gone. 95% confidence intervals: Claude 10.1% to 17.9%, Wikipedia 6.4% to 13.3%. Source: ProofSnap analysis.

What it means

Link rot reaches AI chats: a share link is not a record

The conversation behind a share link stays on the provider's servers, under the control of the account that created it. OpenAI's help center says shared links carry no expiration date, and that deleting the link, the conversation or the account removes it (ChatGPT shared links FAQ). So, according to OpenAI, a share link does not time out. It disappears when its owner deletes the link, the conversation or the account, or when OpenAI disables it; OpenAI lets anyone report a shared link that breaks its rules. The study cannot say which of these removed each lost link. A link from a personal account is also a snapshot: messages added after it was created do not appear unless the owner updates it, so even a live link may not show the whole conversation.

This is link rot, applied to a new kind of source. Whatever the cause, a reader who follows a lost link today finds an error page instead of the conversation, with no way to tell what it once said.

Law libraries have studied this for years. The best-known measurement, published in 2014 by Zittrain, Albert and Lessig (127 Harv. L. Rev. F. 176), found reference rot in more than 70% of URLs cited in three Harvard law journals and in 50% of those cited in U.S. Supreme Court opinions. It led to Perma.cc, which archives a page at the moment it is cited.

AI conversations add a complication: the original sits behind a login, so no public archive can see it. A screenshot is the usual substitute, but an image of a chat is easy to fabricate and shows only one screen. The person who has access to the conversation has to make a record that someone else can check later.

Practice

How to save a ChatGPT conversation as evidence, in six steps

A useful record keeps the original files of the conversation page, records when and how they were captured, and seals every file with a SHA-256 hash and an independent timestamp, so that a later change to any file would be detectable. None of this needs a particular tool. It needs to happen while you still have access.

If all you have is someone else's share link, capture the share page now, with its URL and the time. It is a snapshot that its owner can delete at any time, and it may be the only copy you will ever see. The steps below are for the person who has the account.

  1. Open it where it happened

    Use the account in which the conversation took place, and scroll until every message has loaded. Long chats load older messages only on demand.

  2. Capture the full conversation

    Keep the page HTML, a full-page image and the visible text, and record the URL, the time and where that time came from, and the browser. Our guide shows how to capture a whole AI chat.

  3. Capture what shaped the answers

    Custom instructions, saved memories and the model shown are not part of the transcript. Capture them in the same session.

  4. Treat a share link as a separate item

    If one exists, capture it on its own and record its URL. Do not treat it as the original, and do not rely on it staying online.

  5. Download the account export

    In ChatGPT: Settings, Data controls, Export data. Keep the file exactly as downloaded. It is a second representation of the same conversation, produced by the provider.

  6. Hash and timestamp everything

    Compute a SHA-256 hash of every file, then timestamp the list with an RFC 3161 timestamping authority or OpenTimestamps, so anyone can check that nothing changed.

Method and data

How we calculated the figures

  • Sample. All Hacker News comments and stories returned by the Hacker News search API for chatgpt.com/share and chat.openai.com/share. Only complete share IDs (the full 36-character format) were extracted, so a truncated URL could not enter the sample. Each conversation was counted once, dated by its earliest posting: 2,401 conversations from 2,125 posts, posted between May 27, 2023, and November 17, 2026.
  • Check. On November 19, 2026, each conversation was opened at chatgpt.com/share/<id>. A live shared conversation returns a page titled "ChatGPT - " followed by the conversation's title. A missing or removed one returns the bare title "ChatGPT," which we confirmed with a share URL that cannot exist; rendered in a browser, such a page reads "Can't load shared conversation" followed by the ID. A link was also counted as gone if the server answered HTTP 404 (2 of the 478).
  • Second pass. Every link classified as gone was opened a second time the same day. Of the 479, 478 were confirmed and one was reclassified as live.
  • Archive. Each lost conversation was looked up in the Wayback Machine CDX index on November 19, 2026, as chat.openai.com/share/<id>, and the earliest capture with status 200 was downloaded. It counted as holding the conversation if it contained the message text; nine captures held only a redirect to the new domain. Index lookups of chatgpt.com/share/<id> for all 205 lost chatgpt.com links, one live link and playback of one lost link all returned HTTP 403, while a control lookup of the chatgpt.com home page, repeated nine times during the run, returned 200 every time.
  • Link age from the ID. Newer ChatGPT share IDs (third group starting with 8) begin with the creation time as a Unix timestamp in hexadecimal. For the 1,230 such links, the median gap between creating the link and posting it was under two minutes, and no link was created more than two hours after its post (the window in which a Hacker News comment can still be edited). The posting date is therefore a close proxy for the age of the link.
  • Comparison samples. Claude: all 296 claude.ai/share links returned by the same search, opened in headless Chrome; live if the page shows "This is a copy of a chat between Claude and", gone if it redirects to the sign-in page, the response for a share ID that cannot exist. Wikipedia: links to chatgpt.com/share and chat.openai.com/share on 13 language editions, from the MediaWiki API (list=exturlusage), checked like the Hacker News sample. Every link classified as gone in either sample was checked a second time.
  • Limits. The sample consists of links that people chose to post on one technical forum, not all shared conversations. Age is counted from the first posting, so it understates the age of the link. The check shows whether a conversation can still be opened, not why it disappeared. One post often links several conversations by the same author, and those usually share the same fate, so the observations are not fully independent. A single check cannot separate the age of a link from the year it was shared. Confidence intervals were computed by resampling Hacker News posts rather than single links, so that links from the same post count together: 18.1% to 21.8% for the overall rate, and wide for small groups, such as 1.2% to 13.2% for links under three months old. The 315 Gemini share links returned by the search could not be checked, because Google answered the automated requests with an "unusual traffic" page.

Download the data

2,401 rows, CSV, CC BY 4.0: Hacker News item, first posting date, share domain, age at check, result, time of the check (the second check for links classified as gone), a SHA-256 hash of the share ID, so a known link can be matched without publishing the list, and, for lost conversations, whether the Wayback Machine held a copy and when it was made. For lost links under chatgpt.com that column reads not_retrievable_403, because those lookups were refused. One post can appear in several rows when it linked several conversations.

CSV file

Comparison samples: Claude and Wikipedia CSV (566 rows, CC BY 4.0), with the Hacker News item or the Wikipedia page, the result and a hash of the share ID.

Please cite "Radim Motycka (ProofSnap), Survival of ChatGPT share links posted on Hacker News, 2023 to 2026" with a link to this page. Questions about the data: support@getproofsnap.com.

FAQ

Questions about ChatGPT share links

How long does a ChatGPT share link last?

There is no guarantee. In a sample of 2,401 ChatGPT share links posted on Hacker News since May 2023, 19.9% no longer opened the conversation on November 19, 2026. Among links posted more than two years earlier, 24.4% were gone, and among links three to twelve months old, 17.8%.

Why does a ChatGPT share link stop working?

Not because it expires: OpenAI's help center says shared links have no expiration date. The link stops working when the account holder deletes the link or the conversation, or deletes the account, and OpenAI accepts reports of shared links that break its rules. This study shows that a conversation can no longer be opened, not which of these happened.

What does "Can't load shared conversation" mean?

It is what a removed ChatGPT share link shows: the message "Can't load shared conversation", followed by the conversation's ID, and a button back to ChatGPT. The link, its conversation or the account behind it was deleted, or the link was disabled. The page does not say which, and the conversation cannot be recovered from the link.

Can I recover a ChatGPT conversation after its share link stops working?

Not from the link. If only the link was deleted, the conversation may still be in the owner's account and in its data export, so ask the owner. If the link used the old chat.openai.com address, look it up in the Wayback Machine under that address: in this study it held a copy for 76 of 273 such lost links (27.8%). Lookups of chatgpt.com/share addresses returned HTTP 403.

What happens when you share a ChatGPT conversation?

ChatGPT creates a public URL under chatgpt.com/share/ that anyone who has it can open. For a personal account, the page is a snapshot of the conversation at that moment. The conversation itself stays in the owner's account, so the URL works only until the link, the conversation or the account is deleted, or OpenAI disables the link. In this study, 19.9% of shared links no longer opened.

Are ChatGPT shared links indexed by Google?

Not any more. In August 2025, after shared chats began appearing in Google results, OpenAI removed the "Make this chat discoverable" option and asked search engines to drop the indexed chats. A share link is still public to anyone who has the URL.

Does a ChatGPT share link show messages added later?

Not for a personal account. OpenAI's help center describes such a link as a snapshot: messages sent after it was created do not appear unless the owner updates the link. Business, Enterprise and Edu workspace links work differently. So a live link may still show less than the conversation does now.

Is a ChatGPT share link good evidence of what the AI said?

Not on its own. It points to a copy that the platform controls, and it can stop working at any time. Treat it as one item to capture, alongside a capture of the full conversation in the account where it took place, the settings that shaped the answers and the account data export, all hashed and timestamped.

How do I cite a ChatGPT or Claude conversation?

APA Style now recommends citing a specific chat by its share URL: the company as author, the date, the chat's title with [Generative AI chat], the tool or model, and the URL, because readers must be able to retrieve a source (APA Style blog, September 2025). A share URL alone does not guarantee that: in this study, 19.9% of ChatGPT and 13.5% of Claude share links posted on Hacker News no longer opened. Keep your own copy of the conversation, hashed and timestamped, and, where your editor or instructor agrees, put the prompts and answers in an appendix or supplemental material, as APA suggests for prompts.

Can a public archive save a ChatGPT conversation?

Rarely. In this study the Wayback Machine held a copy of 76 of the 478 lost conversations (15.9%), all shared under the old chat.openai.com address, and it answered every lookup of a chatgpt.com/share address we tried with HTTP 403. The conversation inside your account sits behind a login, so no public archive can see it. The person with access has to make the record.

How do I preserve a ChatGPT conversation as evidence?

Open the conversation in the account where it took place and load it completely. Capture the full conversation with the URL, time and environment recorded, then the custom instructions, memories and model shown. Capture any share link separately, download the account export, hash every file with SHA-256 and timestamp the list.

How do I export a ChatGPT conversation?

On the web, open Settings, then Data controls, and choose Export under Export data. ChatGPT sends a link to a ZIP file with your chat history, and the link expires 24 hours after it arrives. Business and Enterprise workspaces have no self-service export. The export cannot bring back chats that were already deleted, so request it while the conversation still exists.

Do Claude and Gemini share links disappear too?

Claude links do. Of 296 Claude share links posted on Hacker News, 40 (13.5%) no longer opened the conversation on November 19, 2026. Gemini could not be measured, because Google answered the automated checks with an "unusual traffic" page.

Can I use the data?

Yes. The CSV file is published under CC BY 4.0. Please cite "Radim Motycka (ProofSnap), Survival of ChatGPT share links posted on Hacker News, 2023 to 2026" with a link to this page.

While you still have access

Capture the conversation, not just the link

ProofSnap runs in your own browser, so it can capture a conversation in your account. For ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini, it scrolls the conversation pane itself, up to 50 screens, and stitches the screens into one full-page image, then seals the image, the HTML and the text in one package with SHA-256 hashes and a signed manifest. Anyone can check the package in the free Trust Verifier.

Have a shared chat captured for you